Postby Hair-Metal Hero » Thu Oct 14, 2010 10:06 am
I know Zombie's a huge film fan, and I can appreciate the fact that he went for broke. I think in the end his attempt fell very flat for me. Snyder's "Dead" worked for me, and I really didn't want it to at the time, but that film also was closer thematically to Romero's. It took the same basic set up but ramped everything up and added enough new elements to make it unique, but familiar. The less said about the Chainsaw remakes the better. I'm not a huge TCM fan, but I respect the hell out of the first and what Hooper was able to accomplish with no budget, atmosphere and strong performances. TCM 2 is a hoot, and I respect that film even more for the director being able to satirize his own concept all the while making something entertaining. The remake lacked what I think a lot of remakes lack, Charm. A hungry director is setting out to please you, and themselves. Remakes are almost work for hire, its mercenary filmmaking. Here's this assignment, its an uphill battle, do you want it? I'm not strictly anti-remake, but its such a fine line between clever and homaging and full on carbon copy with a known quantity's name attached to it. The Seven Samurai and The Magnificent Seven is a prime example of this. Both work, extremely well telling the same story under different circumstances for different cultures. I mean, how are we all going to feel in 20 years when E.T. gets remade? Or Raiders of the Lost Ark? Those are some serious shoes to fill, and too much deviation or too much adherance to the source material will sink projects like that.
"I believe in Rock And Roll!"
"The Gods you worship are steel,
At the altar of rock 'n' roll you kneel.
A slave who forever rocks,
Is chained in the devil's locks,
And slain by the bloody axe I wail!"