Saw it yesterday, and have no idea what everyone's problem was leading up to this, because I thought it was great!
As I walked out, I had to ask myself if I was sure I liked it as a movie or if my excitement of seeing these characters brought to life on screen was clouding my judgment... after all, I remember initially loving Superman Returns and it wasn't until after it came out on video that I realized my sheer happiness at finally seeing another Superman film arrive after such a long hiatus affected my opinion of the movie at the time. But I have to say, I believe this works as a movie!
I saw it at a Cinemark XD theater in 3D -- for those who haven't heard of XD, it's a nice alternative to IMAX. I've seen too many movies on an IMAX screen that weren't actually shot for IMAX and they've all appeared too blown up and fuzzy to me; XD is another HUGE epic presentation, with a floor-to-ceiling, wall-to-wall screen and all digital, and it is breath-taking! Definitely worth it.
You can only do so much with Green Lantern's world when making it a commercial movie; after all, it is a little out there. Just imagine the average, unknowing teenage/young adult female -- who knows nothing about comics but will still see a comic book movie because it looks cool -- and their reaction when they're presented with Tomar-Re's character on the screen. The filmmakers are burdened with an extremely difficult task of making stuff like Tomar-Re believable/acceptable to that girl in the audience, yet keeping him authentic enough without making her go, "Wait, HUH?? What IS this?! This is too weird for me."
One might respond to that by asking me if I think this movie is made for that audience, the one that girl belongs to. Yes, I do. Figures have shown that the teenage and young adult female audience is the primary driving force behind box office sales today. Based on what I've read, it's the reason why the studio wanted a Ryan Reynolds-type for this movie -- they say Ryan Reynolds was cast because the ladies love him, and guys want to be bro's with him. He does bring the ladies to the theater. For those who think my point here isn't very strong, then tell me why the studio's third choice for the role (if they couldn't get either Bradley Cooper or Reynolds) was Justin Timberlake. I know, right?!? That was a close one. Whew!
Back to the film, I saw it with a friend and my brother-in-law. They both loved it as well... my brother-in-law knew just a little bit about Green Lantern's background before seeing it, but my other friend watched it not knowing anything about the story before going in. Having said that, it was awesome hearing his "What?!? No way!!" reaction to that cliffhanger they showed during the credits. To those of us who know the littlest bit of Green Lantern's story it is not a spoiler at all; but I was wondering beforehand that if they showed this particular thing happen in the movie, if it would be convincing to an unknowing audience... well, my friend is living proof.
And a good time was had by all...

Long-time podcast(s) listener, all too occasional forum contributor.
My Twitter @RadioFuqua